How Much Does It Cost to Fly From New York to San Juan, Puerto Rico, Post-Spirit? 

By: - May 4th, 2026
old san juan
Old San Juan, Puerto Rico.

Travelers are still beginning to process the impact of the departure of Spirit Airlines, which had an outsized network in the Caribbean.

For some routes, Spirit was the only airline operating them — and recovering from those voids will take some time —and initiative from existing carriers. 

But for others, Spirit was simply the cheapest — at least that was the perception. 

A closer look reveals that Spirit wasn’t always the cheapest fare available, and that cheaper fares still remain available from other carriers. 

The best example? New York-LaGuardia to San Juan. 

Last week, fares from New York to San Juan on Spirit were running around $320 roundtrip. 

Today, I found a nonstop route from New York to San Juan, Puerto Rico on JetBlue for only $257 — along with $257 on United and $297 on Delta. 

That covers the end of May and early June, based on Google Flights portal data.

Rates on Spirit’s LGA-SJU route had continued to extend in the $300s for most of the next few months, according to what’s still shown on an extant portion of Spirit’s website. 

In other words, from an affordability standpoint, not necessarily a seismic change — and several great fares still persist. Whether that remains the case is another questions, without Spirit’s ability to set a floor for airfare pricing.

About the author

Alexander Britell is the founder and editor-in-chief of Caribbean Journal and one of the top experts on Caribbean travel worldwide, with decades of on-the-ground travel to the region and comprehensive knowledge of the entire Caribbean Basin.
News

Spirit Airlines Has Shut Down. Here’s What It Means For Caribbean Travel Right Now.

spirit airlines caribbean shut down

It was something you’d always see on Google Flights. Punch in an itinerary — Fort Lauderdale to San Juan, Boston to Cancun. Among the rows of airfares, one was always at the top – the Spirit fare. It was almost universally the cheapest. Now, that line is gone. At Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport, the rhythm […]

News

This New Cayman Islands Wellness Destination Has a Snow Room, a Panoramic Sauna, and a 7-Part Hydrotherapy Circuit

cayman islands meraki

A new kind of wellness destination has opened along Grand Cayman’s Seven Mile Beach — one built entirely around hydrotherapy, temperature contrast, and high-tech treatments, all under one roof. It’s called Meraki Wellness, and it’s the Cayman Islands’ first standalone luxury wellness and spa destination, now officially open at 1411 West Bay Road following a ribbon-cutting ceremony led by Her […]

Flights

Porter Airlines Is Adding Nonstop Flights to Another Destination in the Caribbean This Winter

aruba canadians

Porter Airlines is adding another Caribbean route — and this time it’s Aruba. The Canadian carrier, which recently entered the region with flights to The Bahamas, is now launching new nonstop service from Toronto and Ottawa to Aruba for the Winter 2026 season, adding more lift and more direct options at a time when demand is at […]


This Caribbean-Coast City in Colombia Is Getting New Flights from Fort Lauderdale

JetBlue is expanding again in Colombia, this time with a new nonstop to one of the country’s key Caribbean cities. The airline will launch daily service to Barranquilla, Colombia, beginning Oct. 1, adding a new connection between South Florida and Colombia’s northern coast. The Route Details The new service will operate once daily into Ernesto Cortissoz International Airport, […]

Carnival’s Celebration Key In The Bahamas Is Now The First Sensory-Inclusive Cruise Destination

Carnival Cruise Line’s new destination in Grand Bahama was built around long stretches of sand, large pools and high-capacity shore experiences designed for thousands of cruise passengers at a time. It’s one of the biggest private destinations in the Caribbean right now. And now Celebration Key has been certified by KultureCity as a sensory-inclusive destination, […]

Royal Caribbean Has A 3-Day Miami-To-The Bahamas Cruise For $618 Right Now

JetBlue is expanding again in Colombia, this time with a new nonstop to one of the country’s key Caribbean cities. The airline will launch daily service to Barranquilla, Colombia, beginning Oct. 1, adding a new connection between South Florida and Colombia’s northern coast. The Route Details The new service will operate once daily into Ernesto Cortissoz International Airport, […]

JetBlue Is Launching Two New Routes To Puerto Rico, Including A Nonstop Ponce Flight, Expanded Aguadilla Access, and A New Baltimore Connection

A paper tray in your hand, still warm, stacked with golden tostones, crisp at the edges and soft in the center, salted just enough. Next to them, a row of empanadillas, their shells blistered and crackling, giving way to hot fillings the moment you break them open. Then the heavier bite — alcapurrias, fried deep and dense, the […]

SUBSCRIBE!

Sign up for Caribbean Journal's free newsletter for a daily dose of beaches, hotels, rum and the best Caribbean travel information on the net.


No. Thank You