The 25 Best Best Beach Bars in the Caribbean for 2025, From Aruba to St Barth to Eleuthera

Reggae Beach Bar, St Kitts The southwestern peninsula of St Kitts is the island’s party piece, a sprawling, spectacularly scenic stretch of green hills and beautiful beaches crowned by Cockleshell Bay, a beach we’ve long loved for its impressive surfeit of bars. But our favorite has long been Reggae Beach, the uber-popular spot with the island’s best rum punch and a plum perch at the end of the coastline. (Make sure you have some of the panko-crusted mahi fingers, too).
Alexander Britell is the founder and editor-in-chief of Caribbean Journal and one of the top experts on Caribbean travel worldwide, with decades of on-the-ground travel to the region and comprehensive knowledge of the entire Caribbean Basin.