Op-Ed: Jamaica’s Mistake on Israel

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - January 1, 2013

By David Rowe
Op-Ed Contributor

 

I WAS DISAPPOINTED that Jamaica voted in favour of the United Nations resolution which lifted the Palestinian Authority from an entity to a non-member observer.

Both Israel and the United States opposed the resolution as being largely counterproductive and symbolic.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, speaking at the Brookings Institution, indicated the US position that the Resolution would “do nothing to advance the peace and the two-state solution we all want to see.”

United States Ambassador to the United Nations Susan Rice issued a statement after the vote stating “the only way to establish such a Palestinian state and resolve all permanent-status issues is through the crucial, if painful, work of direct negotiations between the parties.”

The United Kingdom abstained from voting for the Resolution because of a perceived lack of Palestinian commitment to resuming peace negotiations with Israel.  When that assurance did not arise, Britain abstained.

According to Ambassador Raymond Wolfe’s statement following the vote, Jamaica’s decision was “based on a firm commitment to a just and lasting peace in the Middle East region.”

Such a peace could only be brought about by a negotiated settlement; Jamaica sought a balanced approach to the issue, which recognized, among other things, Israel’s right to exist, he said.

“In Jamaica’s view, the granting of Non-Member Observer State status was on the same level as the status afforded to the Holy See delegation,” he said. “It was not equivalent to membership in the United Nations.”

But why did Jamaica find itself voting for a United Nations Resolution that neither the United Kingdom nor the United states voted for?

It is clear that all stakeholders, including most Israeli interests, are in favour of the right of the Palestinian people to live in peaceful coexistence with Israel. I do not see how the resolution advances this position.

At the time of the vote, Palestine already enjoyed full observer status. The significance of the resolution was the specific reference to Palestine as a state. Palestine is simply not currently a state currently under International Law, however. Among Palestinians there is fundamental controversy about which faction should be in control and what should constitute the very essence of the Palestinian state.

Rendering the Palestinians “state status” will not heal the many internal dissensions between the Palestinian Authority in control of the West Bank and Hamas in control of Gaza. In fact, Israel does not know which representative Palestinian faction to engage in binding negotiations with.

Jamaica has voted for a United Nations Resolution which refers to borders that embrace Gaza and the West Bank within a single coherent Palestinian State. Obviously, this does not exist.

There is no international agreement on Hamas as the prospective representative directorate for the new Palestinian State. As Abbott and Costello would say, “Who’s on First?”

The United Nations cannot create a state of Palestine which is not consistent with practical reality. The leader of the Palestinian Authority,  Mahmoud Abbas, lobbied the United Nations Resolution purely to create political leverage with Israel.

Jamaica has a strong historical relationship with Jews and Israel.

In 1494, Luis De Torres, a marrano Jewish interpreter for Columbus landed on the Island.

In 1530, an entire group of Portuguese and Spanish Jews landed in Jamaica fleeing from religious persecution, and Sephardic (Jews of Spanish heritage) were among the island’s first settlers.

In 1831, a decision by the England-based Privy Council granted the Jewish community in Jamaica official recognition and political equality in Jamaica.

And since 1962, there have been full diplomatic ties between Israel and Jamaica. Sephardic Jews were among the earliest settlers in Jamaica.

Israel has recently offered to help Jamaica find alternative sources of energy (an area in which Israel has made a number of technological advancements) that could ease its balance of payment problems. Jamaica should seek to preserve these ties.

With such a rich relationship between Jamaica, its Jewish community and Israel, it was odd that the government of Jamaica embraced a United Nations vote that was clearly contrary to Israeli interests. To some, Jamaica’s pro-Palestinian vote may have seemed an unnecessary stab in the back.

Note: the opinions expressed in Caribbean Journal Op-Eds are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Caribbean Journal.

David P Rowe is an attorney in Jamaica and Florida and a law professor at the University of Miami School of Law in Coral Gables, Fla.

Popular Posts ian fleming villa with beach and green trees

American Airlines Begins New Ocho Rios, Jamaica Flights, With a Nod to James Bond 

Ian Fleming began writing the book that would become Casino Royale at his seaside villa in the town of Oracabessa, Jamaica in February 1952.  It was here on the outskirts of Ocho Rios that Fleming would forge the story of […]


A New All-Inclusive W Hotel Is Opening This Year in Punta Cana 

w punta cana

The first-ever all-inclusive W Hotel in the Caribbean is opening this year in Punta Cana, Dominican Republic, Caribbean Journal has learned.  The hotel, part of a broad expansion for parent company Marriott International, is on the list of expected 2024 […]


Why Grenada Is a New Caribbean Luxury Hotspot

beach house silversands

From its world-renowned chocolate to its pristine beaches to a region-leading focus on sustainability, Grenada is as fascinating and unique as destination as you’ll find in the Caribbean.  But in the last few years, the lush Eastern Caribberan island has […]


Related Posts doctors cave beach with waves

Jamaica Adding New Automated Passport Kiosks

In a a bid to expedite processing at two of the Caribbean’s busiest airports, Jamaica is adding new automated passport control kiosks in Kingston and Montego Bay.  The new kiosks aim to “streamline passenger flow,” according to a statement from […]


The Cool List: the Coolest Hotels in the Caribbean for 2024

the cool list 2024

They’re different. They’re fun, they’re colorful, they’re unique. They’re themselves. The Caribbean has no shortage of cool hotels and in this, Caribbean Journal’s 12th annual Cool List, we highlight the places that hit you in a different way, that do […]


The 25 Best All-Inclusive Resorts in the Caribbean, from Adults-Only to Boutique

hammock cove in antigua

What is an all-inclusive resort? In recent years, the answer to that question has changed dramatically. Today, all-inclusive means a resort that is at the cutting edge of travel trends, one that is catering to the demands of a massive […]


SUBSCRIBE!

Sign up for Caribbean Journal's free newsletter for a daily dose of beaches, hotels, rum and the best Caribbean travel information on the net.


No. Thank You