CJ Politics

Op-Ed: Elections and Democracy in the Turks and Caicos Islands

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - November 1, 2012

By Erik Neff
Op-Ed Contributor

Nov. 9 sparks a new beginning for the Turks and Caicos Islands (TCI). Wracked by corruption, the overseas territory has been directly ruled by the United Kingdom since 2009.

This November will be the first time the territory has had elections since the commencement of British control.

The catalyst for Britain’s controversial governance and ethical bailout was Sir Robin Auld’s Commission of Inquiry Report 2008-09 on the alleged high probability of corruption in the TCI government.

Auld brought to light a decade’s worth of allegations of unscrupulous business transactions, nepotism, the selling of Crown land, and the imposition of a culture of fear over the territory’s 45,000 inhabitants by the governing elite.

Auld stated that little had changed in TCI except for the range and scale of corruption since Sir Louis Blom-Cooper’s Commission of Inquiry Ordinance report in 1986.

At the head of the troubles was the former Premier, Michael Misick, whose whereabouts are currently unknown.

When Gordon Wetherell took executive and legislative power as Governor, the only real initial outcry over the imposition of British rule was from Misick and investors.

Now, more than three years later, TCI has a new constitution, and is awaiting the trials of its charged maligns before Judge Paul Harrison of Jamaica.

An interesting dialogue has arisen from the recent turmoil dealing with Caribbean self-determination and the helicopter colonialism dichotomy.

While Britain is loosening its grip upon the TCI, it leaves behind an invasive precedent.

Britain’s move to suspend parliament and take over the day-to-day governance of the TCI has been heavily criticized by both locals and the Caribbean Community.

The precedent is unnerving for any small territory under British oversight. It effectively creates a double edged sword — live in fear due to corrupt local governmental practices, or be swaddled in recolonization and lose your autonomy. Neither choice is appetizing.

Whatever one’s view of him, former Premier Misick made a salient point that “[i]n a democracy mistakes are made as they are made in Britain and in all other countries around the world, but democracy must be allowed to grow and mature, despite the trials and errors.”

It is interesting that in the attempt to rekindle democracy and the public trust that Britain took to dissolving the symbol of democracy in the Westminster system, Parliament.

Yet, what was Britain to do?

It could not stand idly by as its interests, the people and land, were ransacked. Act and be called a colonizer, or allow its sovereign interests in the TCI to be harmed by the hands of local Machiavellians. In the end, the constitutional and executive solution to the treatment of the island by its inhabitants was British.

However, with the arrival of Judge Harrison to the Supreme Court of the Turks and Caicos, the solution as to the implementation of law is squarely in the hands of the people of the TCI.

Whereas Britain may have dictated the laws and governmental structure of the TCI, it is not in control of the disposition of the law against those charged by the SIPT.

Perhaps after this turmoil, democracy can once again grow and mature in the TCI.

Erik A Neff is a JD/LLM candidate at the University of Miami School of Law.

Note: the opinions expressed in Caribbean Journal Op-Eds are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Caribbean Journal.

Popular Posts belize hotel mayan world

At the Falling Leaves Lodge in Belize, a Portal to the Maya World

SAN IGNACIO — There has been some form of settlement on this site for more than 3,000 years, here on a leafy hill above the town of San Ignacio, Belize. In other words, this is no ordinary hill. This is Cahal Pech, […]

In San Ignacio, Belize, The Art of Adventure (And Pupusas)

pupusas belize

The sizzle is calling you. In the early morning, corn tortillas stuffed with cheese and beans and meat sing a particularly strong siren song.  It could be that perfect blend of dough and heat, or the aroma. It might just […]

Delta Is Adding More Nonstop Curacao Flights, Citing “Booming Demand”  

the beach at the avila hotel in curacao

Curacao is hotter than ever, with a wave of new hotels and record-breaking tourism numbers. And just a few months after Delta made its long-awaited return to the island, the carrier is adding even more flights.  The reason? What Delta […]

Related Posts turks and caicos

Ian Hurdle Appointed President of Turks and Caicos Real Estate Association

Ian Hurdle, founder and director of The Agency’s Turks and Caicos office, has been appointed as the new president of the Turks and Caicos Real Estate Association. Hurdle is a leading figure in Turks and Caicos’ luxury market and that […]

American Airlines Is Adding More Daily Flights to the Turks and Caicos Islands

dragon cay turks hotels

The world’s largest airlines is making moves in the Caribbean again, with plans for a significant summer push that includes an expansion to the buzzy Turks and Caicos Islands.  Next spring, American will be ramping up its Miami-Providenciales route to […]

Turks and Caicos Beach Estate Hits the Market for $13.5M

Blue Cay Turks and Caicos

The Blue Cay Beach Estate in Turks and Caicos has hit the market for $13.5 million, Caribbean Journal Invest has learned. The home, which was built in 2019, is listed by Christie’s International Real Estate. “The property will be a […]


Sign up for Caribbean Journal's free newsletter for a daily dose of beaches, hotels, rum and the best Caribbean travel information on the net.

No. Thank You