Taste Anegada Lobster Famously flat Anegada is separated from her siblings by 15 miles, so if you make it all the way here make your visit count by heading to Loblolly Bay, an idyllic 17-mile strip of sand. Here you’ll find Big Bamboo, a beachfront bar and restaurant that serves the island’s famous lobster (and potent rum punch) that alone make the trip worthwhile.