Sugar Mill Hotel, Tortola, British Virgin Islands The Sugar Mill has long been Tortola’s destination eatery, the sort of grand, historic restaurant whose dinner often becomes the highlight of a traveler’s visit. But this eatery is also home to a lovely little boutique hotel, with 24 rooms across 8 buildings just steps across from the water. It’s a trip back in time, and one for which you may only want to buy a one-way ticket.