Op-Ed: A New Jamaica Labour Party?

By: - November 10th, 2013

By David Rowe
Op-Ed Contributor

BY THE CLOSE of day Sunday, the Jamaica Labour Party will have chosen its next leader — incumbent and former Prime Minister Andrew Holness or challenger and former Finance Minister Audley Shaw.

Holness represents the youth of the JLP, which first developed out of the personality of Jamaican hero Alexander Bustamante, the country’s first Prime Minister.

By all accounts, he is considered as a man with a strong political future, unassociated with much of the problems that have plagued Jamaican politics: garrison politics and violent elements of society.

Shaw is the institutional candidate, a bold longtime MP who announced his challenge to Holness’ leadership in mid-September.

It has thus far been a heated race, with all of the usual charges leveled, and some new ones (including allegations of plagiarism of Holness’ “Five E” plan, which covers the environment, energy, economy, education and either empowerment or efficiency, depending on whom you ask. (Note: whoever used its first almost certainly borrowed it from Haiti President Michel Martelly, who has made a similar “Five E” plan a major prong of his administration).

But the most pressing issue for the JLP is not who will lead the party and who will win this impassioned race, but what the party will stand for.

Is it the party of Seaga? Is it the party of Bustamante? Is it the party of Golding? Is it something else entirely? Is it, perhaps, time for a New Labour, in the vein of Tony Blair?

What will be the role of the new JLP starting Monday — and what kind of opposition will it stand for, with an election still three years away?

And in a society where colorism continues to be a major, if largely ignored problem, will the new JLP help transcend longstanding tensions between different strata of Jamaican society?

Of course, another possibility remains — that the party could see itself splintered between support for both men.

Could a new party emerge to challenge the two-party system in Jamaica?

The history of third parties in the Caribbean is not impressive — most recently, a once-promising Democratic National Alliance in the Bahamas failed to win any seats in that country’s 2012 vote.

But in Jamaica, anything can happen.

David P Rowe is an attorney in Jamaica and Florida and an adjunct law professor at the University of Miami School of Law in Coral Gables, Fla.

Note: the opinions expressed in Caribbean Journal Op-Eds are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Caribbean Journal.

 

Opinion

Should Caribbean Politicians Tweet?

By Marcia Forbes, PhD CJ Contributor Politicians & Social Media Engagement THE QUESTION keeps coming back – social media and Jamaican politicians; do they know how to use these communication tools to their advantage? Recently, it seems that whenever there is an election in Jamaica, politicians take to social media. They do not always score […]

Opinion

A New Way For Trinidad and Jamaica to Work Together

By Paul Hay CJ Contributor William Demas, former Head of the Economic and Planning Division of the Government of Trinidad and Tobago,  compared the five-year national plans of Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago (T&T) in his book The Economics of Development in Small Countries, first published in 1965, and noted that: “…both plans anticipate a […]

Opinion

Is Jamaica on the Right Track?

By Dennis Chung CJ Contributor OVER the past few weeks, I have been approached by many persons who ask the questions: What is happening to the economy? Is Jamaica headed in the right direction? Is it time for me to migrate? These questions have been influenced by the continued devaluation of the Jamaican dollar, increasing […]

The Perfect Jamaican Curry Chicken

 By Nigel Spence CJ Contributor I WAS thinking this week about the “government Shutdown” here in the US and how people in certain circumstances were being affected. There was an alleged report of angry customers at Walmart because their EBT cards stopped working at the registers.  The EBT card is issued instead of food stamps […]

Op-Ed: What the Shanique Myrie Case Means for Caribbean Law

 By J. Emile Ferdinand QC Op-Ed Contributor THE SIGNIFICANCE of the Caribbean Court of Justice’s (“CCJ”) judgment delivered on Oct. 4, 2013 in the case of Myrie v Barbados arises more from the reasoning and related pronouncements of the Court than from the actual decision in Ms Myrie’s favour. Ms Myrie brought the case against […]

Trust and Development in Jamaica

 By Nigel Spence CJ Contributor I WAS thinking this week about the “government Shutdown” here in the US and how people in certain circumstances were being affected. There was an alleged report of angry customers at Walmart because their EBT cards stopped working at the registers.  The EBT card is issued instead of food stamps […]

Dennis Chung: Behaviour and Economic Growth in Jamaica

 By Dennis Chung CJ Contributor LAST SATURDAY I was with my cycling group for the ride out to Palisadoes and back. After getting to the airport roundabout we usually turn and go back to Harbour View before heading back to the airport. While going around the roundabout, a man who was on a bicycle, heading […]