On Tortola: Lighthouse Villas, Cane Garden Bay, Sugar Mill Hotel, Apple Bay The town of Cane Garden Bay has a beautiful beach backed by a row of lively beach bars and restaurants, with the 400-year-old Callwood Rum Distillery just down the road. Some of those eateries are incorporated into modest beach hotels, like Myett’s Garden Inn, but we were charmed by the Lighthouse Villas, which were across the street and uphill from the beach and had spacious villas with lovely views of the bay. The elegant Sugar Mill on Apple Bay is another excellent choice on Tortola, with colonial-style rooms and the namesake dining room across from a private stretch of beach and the Mediteranean-style Tramonti restaurant.