Op-Ed: Leading Sustainable Tourism in the Caribbean

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - July 22, 2014

By Ryan Peterson
Op-Ed Contributor

IT IS a truism that tourism is experiencing a tectonic transformation.

In recent times, the global tourism and travel industry, and in particular, Small-Island Tourism-Economies (SITES) in the Caribbean have had to contend with a series of unprecedented and disruptive social, technical, economic and ecological and challenges. In effect, SITES are coming full cycle, and are experiencing the pressures and prowess to re-experiment and re-invent tourism as they did almost five decades ago.

As SITES venture into the new reality of the 21st century, they face considerable uncertainty, volatility, and ambiguity, which will require nothing less than an equally tectonic shift in not only reforming sustainable tourism development, but more importantly, transforming sustainable tourism leadership.

The quest at hand is not the reform in balancing existing and future social, economic and ecological stakes, but in how SITES transcend these traditional transactions, in order to transform and lead sustainable tourism in a holistic fashion.

While political debates and economic discussions on sustainable tourism in the Caribbean have been bent and bandied for several decades now, what is less scrutinized is the need and emergence of transformational leadership for sustainable tourism. Akin to installing solar panels on a house, without questioning the integral foundation and architecture of the house, SITES have been reforming tourism policies and developments, without re-thinking and re-designing the leadership foundations, subsequently inducing unsustainable sustainable tourism.

To understand this emerging shift towards leading sustainable tourism in the Caribbean, it essential that we place this within the historical and contemporary political-economic context of Caribbean SITES. As relatively experienced tourism-intense island economies, SITES are facing the trials and tribulations of a mature tourism-economy in a hyper-competitive environment, in which the confluence of several disruptive innovations are pressuring the traditional ‘product and policy’ paradigm of tourism and its sustainable development.

Generally speaking, SITES define themselves by a complex adaptive web of dynamic interdependencies between intrinsically unpredictable complex systems, involving economic, social, ecological, and institutional (f)actors.

As SITES mature in a dynamic environment, they evolve through different spheres, and increasingly operate on the ‘edge-of-chaos’, in which SITES exist in a fuzzy state of dynamic flux, oftentimes experienced as temporal states of crisis by policy-makers, executives, and island communities.

In effect, SITES increasingly experience strategic discontinuities and multiple dynamic equilibria in their development.

This is in stark contrast, however, with the traditional principles and policies of sustainable tourism.

The concept of sustainability, although polymorphous, refers primarily to an ability to maintain a system in a steady continuous state, and is based on principles of equity, equilibrium, durability, and continuity, in which stability is essential for maintaining, conserving, and preserving a -social, cultural, ecological or economic- system. Nevertheless, within the context of disruptive innovations, this perspective induces systemic entropy and stimulates inertia, due to its non-adaptive strategy and ‘atomistic’ approach.

In more unambiguous terms, while SITES have matured in managing the singular terms and transactions of economic, social and ecological dimensions in tourism development, the need for transcending and transforming these ‘atoms’ of sustainable tourism, presents a clear and present need for leadership and leading sustainable tourism in a holistic (non-atomistic) fashion.

In effect, the acclaimed ‘sustainability triangle’ of economic, social and ecological developments and impacts is pointless, if transformational leadership and the transcendence of atomistic transactions are not acknowledged and development. Transformational leadership is the new chariot of sustainability, and without shared values, due diligence, knowledge relationships and strategic governance, ‘sustainable tourism’ will remain flawed in conceptualization, futile in execution, and fleeting in sustainability.

The confluence of classical transactional policies and the emerging need for transformational leadership has created, paradoxically enough, a non-sustainable framework for addressing, let alone guiding, the sustainability of SITES. Lacking a comprehensive framework for understanding the clash of forces in today’s world, we are like a ship’s crew, trapped in a storm and trying to navigate without compass or chart. Or yes, installing state-of-the-art green energy technologies, without rethinking and redesigning the underlying green infrastructure and architecture.

In a culture of crusading disciplines and disciples, drowned in disjointed praxis, perspectives and paralysis, creative deconstruction and transformational leadership of sustainable tourism are not only necessary – they are strategic imperatives for the present and future of sustainable tourism in the Caribbean.

Ryan Peterson, PhD is Professor of Innovation Economics and Research Chair in Sustainable Islands at the University of Aruba. He can be reached at ryan.peterson@ua.aw.

Note: the opinions expressed in Caribbean Journal Op-Eds are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Caribbean Journal.

Popular Posts the sexiest beaches including this resort at atlantis

The Sexiest Beaches in the Caribbean to Visit Right Now 

One is a beach with a nightclub-style pool right next door. Another is filled with beach bars — and even has its own au natural corner. Then there’s a beach that’s practically a nonstop party.  There are so many things that […]

The Best Caribbean Islands to Visit This Summer, From Antigua to St Croix

verandah antigua

We’ve been saying it for years, and we’ll keep saying it: in some ways, the Caribbean is even better in the summer months. The water is warm. It’s a bit less crowded, a little bit quieter. At night, the trade […]

The Winners of the 2024 Caribbean Green Awards 

caribbean green

With almost 20,000 votes, the winners of the Caribbean Green Awards 2024 Presented by E-Finity have been crowned.  From state-of-the-art marine conservation projects to hotels that are redefining sustainability, the Green movement has never been stronger in the Caribbean.  “This […]

Related Posts bahamas small hotels

Caribbean Hotels Keep Filling Up as Travel Demand Strengthens 

It was a very strong March for the Caribbean hotel industry, according to the newest data from hotel analytics firm STR.  Hotel occupancy was 76.4 percent last month, a sizable 7.3 percent jump over March 2023 — a very strong […]

American Airlines Is Adding More Daily Nonstop Flights to Dominica

dominica fort young

Fresh off the news that American Airlines would be running daily flights to Dominica for much of the summer, the world’s largest airline has plans to extend that service.  American Airlines already announced that it would be operating daily nonstop […]

Dominican Republic Cruise Tourism Keeps Growing 

celebrity cruises ship docked at port

It’s no secret that the Dominican Republic is the most popular destination in the Caribbean, as measured by air visitors.  But the country’s cruise industry has quietly been seeing rapid growth, too.  Indeed, the Dominican Republic welcomed just under 867,000 […]


Sign up for Caribbean Journal's free newsletter for a daily dose of beaches, hotels, rum and the best Caribbean travel information on the net.

No. Thank You