Op-Ed: Jamaica’s Crime Resurgence

By: - July 7th, 2012

By Ramesh Sujanani
Op-Ed Contributor

IT IS ALARMING to find that gang warfare and crime have escalated in Jamaica, encompassing murder, rape, extortion and all of those auxiliary violent crimes — in addition to which, Jamaica’s reputation in human trafficking has deteriorated.

It is interesting to note that this resurgence is coincidental with the closure of Operation Kingfish, and the departure of AC Les Green, the officer on secondment from the United Kingdom.

It was my impression that other officers from the USA and Canada would be taking their place, and I hope that the Minister of Security would enlighten us on what is happening.

But there are some pertinent questions here that I would like to ask the Ministry: Why disband Kingfish, was it not serving a useful purpose? Is it not possible to place another officer in charge, a Jamaican if available? What has happened to the officers that used to be in Kingfish? Why are these energies not channeled into this scourge of human trafficking?

Human trafficking is the illegal trade in human beings mainly for sexual exploitation, or forced labour — a modern version of slavery.

Around 80 percent of persons traded are women and girls, with women being 70 percent of that total, used for commercial sex, prostitution, and pornography. In Jamaica, it has been concluded that the women remain in situ earning money, because many victims are illiterate and going out in the world means earning less money.

There are opinions circulating that this change in crime management creates a window being used by the parties for the purpose of various nefarious activities, such as importing guns, human trafficking, and drugs. It seems that human trafficking is the number two earner among the three, with narcotics being number one.

A few years ago the “Palermo protocols” laid the groundwork for a tiered system, in which Jamaica was placed at the number-two tier. It seems that it may slip to the third tier, consistent with Guyana and Haiti, which is a deterioration of crime control in this area.

Do the reports have any substantive element of truth?
If not, where are the guns coming from? A large group of armed men recently descended into August Town, fully armed, to commit murder. How did they get weapons, sufficient to arm a small militia? Was there not a police presence in the town to put up resistance to keep them away, until reinforcements arrive? It seems we have made a retrograde step.

The quality of our Government once again is approaching that of a failed state.

The old excuses — Dudus, Tivoli, socioeconomic conditions, are at the forefront. Dudus and Tivoli are settled issues, and, truly, poverty is the worst form of violence.

But we are all working on relief in that area: the private sector, the government and private citizens, are actively trying to find employment and subsistence for the poor. It has been suggested that the people of August Town support their gangs, which I do not believe.

Then we have the increasing pressure from INDECOM (Jamaica’s Independent Commission of Investigations), which threatens with detailed assessment of police homicides.

While I think this could be a noble pursuit, it is not the right time to place any emphasis there. Emphasis should be on bringing criminals to justice, or to ensuring their termination. Rehabilitation is always a solution, but is it going to work with this current generation of criminals? I would warn against giving the police and law enforcement mixed signals on crime control.

We then need to consider the future impact: crime and violence are one of the main drawbacks in Jamaica’s tourism product.

We should be at a point now of promoting Jamaica’s tourism for 2013 — how will these incidents change our approach?

Can we say that these matters are now being controlled, and approached and that they will not recur, or are we wrapped in a sea of troubles and do not know what to do?

Ramesh K Sujanani can be reached at rsujanani78@gmail.com.

Note: the opinions expressed in Caribbean Journal Op-Eds are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Caribbean Journal.

Jamaica

Haiti’s Path to Change Still Lacks Social Inclusion of the Population

By Ilio Durandis CJ Contributor The word change has been used very loosely in recent decades to describe what must take place in Haiti. From the time Pope John Paul II famously uttered that things must change, during his only visit to Haiti in 1983, to the present day, people in positions of power have […]

Jamaica

Jamaica's Peter Phillips: Small Businesses "Critical" to Economic Rebound

Above: Finance Minister Dr Peter Phillips and Industry Minister Anthony Hylton (JIS Photo) By the Caribbean Journal staff Jamaica’s small business sector is a critical part of the country’s economic recovery, according to Finance Minister Dr Peter Phillips. The Minister said Jamaica’s government is committed to expanding micro, small and medium-sized enterprises in the country. […]

Jamaica

Jamaica's Portia Simpson Miller: Expand CARICOM Free Movement Categories

Above: CARICOM SG Irwin LaRocque and Jamaican PM Portia Simpson Miller (Photo: CARICOM) By the Caribbean Journal staff The Caribbean Community must “embrace” freedom of movement and expand its categories of free movement to include security guards, household helpers and caregivers, according to Jamaica’s Prime Minister, Portia Simpson Miller. Jamaica’s leader, speaking at the opening […]

Op-Ed: Is It Time for Chaguaramas 2.0? Jamaica's Youth Can Lead the Way

 By Fabio Pittaluga Op-Ed Contributor Today, as CARICOM Heads of Government meet to deliberate in Castries, St Lucia, trying to extricate their nations from the crosshairs of the deepest recession since the Community’s 1973 formation by the Treaty of Chaguaramas, the old clock is ticking still but with concern for its future: the digital clock […]

Op-Ed: Drones for the Caribbean?

 By David Rowe Op-Ed Contributor The Obama administration is criticized for not having a distinct Caribbean policy, although that criticism may be too harsh. The administration, through the steady hand of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, has taken a strong anti-narcotics, pro-Rule of Law position, appointing experienced diplomats to Caribbean positions and being intolerant of […]

Cricket: Jamaica's Chris Gayle Moves Up to Fourth in T20 Batting Rankings

 By Fabio Pittaluga Op-Ed Contributor Today, as CARICOM Heads of Government meet to deliberate in Castries, St Lucia, trying to extricate their nations from the crosshairs of the deepest recession since the Community’s 1973 formation by the Treaty of Chaguaramas, the old clock is ticking still but with concern for its future: the digital clock […]

Jamaica Looking at New Diaspora Policy

 Above: State Minister for Foreign Affairs Arnaldo Brown (JIS Photo) By the Caribbean Journal staff Jamaica must undertake to draft a diaspora and development policy, according to State Minister for Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade Arnaldo Brown. Jamaica’s government is looking to instate measures which will reduce the disadvantages associated with migration, he said, instead […]