Op-Ed: Austerity and Growth in Jamaica

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - June 7, 2012

By Ramesh Sujanani
Op-Ed Contributor

Professor Michael Witter, writing in the Jamaica Gleaner, recently outlined a conflict of interest in the management of recession by governments’ policies in the United States and Europe.

It seems that there are two approaches to growth. Reducing expenditure (austerity), or investing more money into projects with a return and production (growth by stimulus).

Following the G8 meeting in this year, certain dividing lines were created between the self-proclaimed policies of US President Barack Obama and new French President Francois Hollande, which were described as pro-growth, and those governments who favored austerity.

Completely absent from any discussions was any sense that an attempt was being made to achieve austerity, as in Jamaica’s case, or that supply-side efforts to spur growth after the crises have subsided have been tried, save some attempts at tax reform.

Did Jamaica practice austerity last year? I would be interested if the amount of expenditure growth showed a relation to austerity; it does, in fact, show that total expenditure declined 10 percent, while total inflows increased by 25 percent, resulting in a virtual increase in expenditure in the fiscal year 2010/2011.

Lost is the idea that what is needed is more production, not more consumption. France’s Hollande outlined that his growth plan is reducing the retirement to age 60 from 62, hiring 60,000 new teachers, raising corporate taxes, and taxing the marginalized tax rate to 75 percent, for incomes over $1,000,000 Euros, and this effort was commended by his peers.

Is this austerity or stimulus? Governments find that these two bounce back quite easily. Stimulus means more government spending, which eventually turns out to be abused by governments and wasted or frittered in crony pay-offs, or turns out to be “unaccounted.”

“Austerity” usually means less spending and higher taxes. Then it turns out nobody wants to restrict spending, especially when the economy is crumbling due to the higher taxes.

Yet some economists are stunned by the way austerity is pushed, especially at a time it is when it is ill-advised.

In 1929/1930, US Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon demanded more austerity and fiscal management, which led in part to the Great Depression of 1930; he raised taxes and cut spending to balance the budget, which was immediately unbalanced because the unemployment rate was rising, and tax revenues were falling.

The continuance of this practice caused the Great Depression to continue for a decade, until the demands of World War II changed the situation. We need to formulate a policy yielding austerity and growth.

Lowering taxes, in the form of  tax reform, will usually turn out to be revenue neutral as a percent of GDP. A flat-tax policy, as dozens of countries have introduced in contemporary situations, would repeatedly yield excellent results.

Asking for fiscal integrity from governments which are faced with 10 percent to 25 percent unemployment is poor social and economic policy, and will only make matters worse.

Austerity may be the policy five or 10 years from now, as at this time it will weaken and depress the Jamaican economy, potentially resulting in a depression, worse than the recession we now suffer.

Less spending should be focused on maintaining the desired government services, but providing those services in an efficient, low- expense manner.

The measures I propose would be to obtain investments that would result in productive enterprise with returns. New taxes will only result in increasing government spending on frivolous causes, and waste.

The headcount of government employees should be reduced to whatever is needed to maintain essential services. Pay-offs and waste should be immediately eliminated.

It is far easier to reduce government spending when the private sector is booming, and jobs are available.

I am reminded that Japanese leaders, after the Meiji restoration in 1868, discarded a tax code containing some 1500 taxes, replacing it with a minimalist system that derived almost all revenue from a simple property tax.

Most of the remaining revenue was raised by a tax on alcoholic beverages.

The new Japanese leaders then eliminated their unneeded Government bureaucrats in one main purge. Sound enticing?

Ramesh K Sujanani can be reached at rsujanani78@gmail.com.

Note: the opinions expressed in Caribbean Journal Op-Eds are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Caribbean Journal.


Popular Posts belize hotel mayan world

At the Falling Leaves Lodge in Belize, a Portal to the Maya World

SAN IGNACIO — There has been some form of settlement on this site for more than 3,000 years, here on a leafy hill above the town of San Ignacio, Belize. In other words, this is no ordinary hill. This is Cahal Pech, […]

In San Ignacio, Belize, The Art of Adventure (And Pupusas)

pupusas belize

The sizzle is calling you. In the early morning, corn tortillas stuffed with cheese and beans and meat sing a particularly strong siren song.  It could be that perfect blend of dough and heat, or the aroma. It might just […]

Delta Is Adding More Nonstop Curacao Flights, Citing “Booming Demand”  

the beach at the avila hotel in curacao

Curacao is hotter than ever, with a wave of new hotels and record-breaking tourism numbers. And just a few months after Delta made its long-awaited return to the island, the carrier is adding even more flights.  The reason? What Delta […]

Related Posts doctors cave beach with waves

Jamaica Adding New Automated Passport Kiosks

In a a bid to expedite processing at two of the Caribbean’s busiest airports, Jamaica is adding new automated passport control kiosks in Kingston and Montego Bay.  The new kiosks aim to “streamline passenger flow,” according to a statement from […]

The Cool List: the Coolest Hotels in the Caribbean for 2024

the cool list 2024

They’re different. They’re fun, they’re colorful, they’re unique. They’re themselves. The Caribbean has no shortage of cool hotels and in this, Caribbean Journal’s 12th annual Cool List, we highlight the places that hit you in a different way, that do […]

The 25 Best All-Inclusive Resorts in the Caribbean, from Adults-Only to Boutique

hammock cove in antigua

What is an all-inclusive resort? In recent years, the answer to that question has changed dramatically. Today, all-inclusive means a resort that is at the cutting edge of travel trends, one that is catering to the demands of a massive […]


Sign up for Caribbean Journal's free newsletter for a daily dose of beaches, hotels, rum and the best Caribbean travel information on the net.

No. Thank You