This St Croix Resort Has Three Beaches, Oceanfront Golf, and a Nearly 80-Year Family Story
At The Buccaneer, you can spend your vacation between palm-shaded sand, seaside fairways and a hillside Great House overlooking Christiansted.
You can have lunch beside Mermaid Beach, spend the afternoon at Grotto, and take a walk over the hill to Whistle Beach when you want a quieter stretch of sand. At The Buccaneer, choosing your beach is part of choosing your day, with three different shorelines on the same sprawling St Croix estate.
Above the water, the pink Great House looks toward Christiansted. Across the grounds, golf fairways follow the coastline, and an old stone sugar mill connects the setting to the island’s earlier history. This is a resort where you can spend a full day outside, moving between the beach, the course and your own ocean-facing terrace.
Three Beaches, Three Different Days
Mermaid Beach is the natural starting point. It’s the resort’s main beach, a palm-shaded, protected stretch with a watersports center and The Mermaid restaurant, so you can settle into a lounge chair without having to plan much beyond your next swim.
Snorkeling equipment, kayaks and paddleboards are included for resort guests. You can take a paddle out into the bay, return for lunch, and spend the rest of the afternoon close to the water.
Grotto Beach puts a freshwater pool and Beauregard’s on the Beach beside another inviting shoreline. Whistle Beach, over the hill, offers a more secluded setting without structures on the sand. That variety earned The Buccaneer a place in our selection of Caribbean resorts with more than one beach to explore.
A Hotel With Its Own Island History
The Armstrong family opened The Buccaneer in 1947 as an 11-room inn. Today, the family-owned resort has 131 rooms across 340 acres, with a history that reaches well beyond its first hotel guests.
The estate dates to 1653, and its sugar mill dates to 1733. You can explore that past through the resort’s history and nature tour, while the weekly Sugar Mill Cocktail Party brings guests together around one of its most distinctive landmarks.
As we explored in our recent Buccaneer feature, the family connection is central to the hotel’s appeal. You’re staying at a place whose story is closely tied to St Croix, with generations of ownership behind the name.
Choosing Your Room
Your room choice can shape the vacation. Great House accommodations put you in the hillside setting, while Deluxe Oceanfront rooms and Luxury Beachside Doubloons offer options closer to the sea.
The Doubloons rooms have 800 square feet of space. Family Cottage Suites have two bedrooms, giving parents and children separate sleeping areas, while larger suites offer additional choices if you’re traveling together.
Rooms have private patios or balconies, giving you somewhere to linger before breakfast or after a beach day. If proximity to the sand is your priority, pay attention to the specific category when reserving; the resort’s broad grounds make location part of the decision.
Golf With the Sea Beside You
The Buccaneer’s 18-hole, par-70 golf course gives you another reason to spend the morning outdoors. Water views accompany the round, and three holes run along Grotto Beach’s shoreline.
There are also eight tennis courts, two illuminated for evening play, along with lessons and clinics. You can alternate a morning on court with an afternoon in the sea, or leave the sporting schedule open and head straight for one of the resort’s two freshwater pools.
From Breakfast to a Beachside Dinner
Daily buffet breakfast is included, served at The Terrace. Lunch at The Mermaid keeps you beside the beach, with salads, wraps and stone-oven pizza among the choices.
Beauregard’s on the Beach adds sushi, seafood, tacos and cocktails beside Grotto, while The Terrace offers evening dining overlooking Christiansted. Together, they give you several ways to stay on property without repeating the same setting.
That’s the attraction of this enduring US Virgin Islands resort: you have enough choices for an active vacation, and three beaches waiting whenever you decide to slow down.
So what about prices? We found rates for $444 on Google Hotels for early next month.
Lori Chase is the Wellness Editor and Senior Travel Contributor at Caribbean Journal, where she covers the intersection of luxury travel, well-being and Caribbean lifestyle. A graduate of Cornell University, her coverage spans integrative wellness programming, nature-driven experiences, sustainable hospitality, and the increasingly sophisticated ecosystems of wellness travel emerging across the islands. Based in South Florida, she has been traveling to the Caribbean for more than a decade. Her favorite island is St Barth.

