scotch recipe caribbean mushrooms
News

A Great Caribbean Mushroom Recipe

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - November 7, 2019

By Nigel Spence

Mushrooms are generally not high on the list of foods that Caribbean folks hold in high regard. That may be because we are not and have never been a mushroom growing or consuming society.

What I was taught when growing up was that mushrooms were poisonous and should be avoided at all costs lest you touch it, keel over and meet your Maker. As I got older the only other mushrooms ever encountered were of the hallucinogenic variety and those too came with tales of going over to the dark side, never to return to normal.

Needless to say, with all these dark tales, there was absolutely no reason for me to further explore the possibilities of mushrooms being a part of my diet.

Then came the girlfriend.

She was Italian, with a good dose of crazy, and quite opinionated.

Among the many firsts I experienced with her, one that I can mention is the introduction to EATING mushrooms.

It was love at first bite (the mushrooms, that is).

It was that savory satisfying food that I didn’t know I needed in my life, unlike the girlfriend who had to move on to someone more in keeping with her character, because at that time it just wasn’t me.

I do thank her for the introduction as it has turned out to be a “happily ever after” story with the fearsome fungus my mom always warned me about.

Mushrooms don’t need a lot of in-depth preparation for it to be awesome; sometimes the simpler the better.

SCOTCH BONNET MUSHROOMS

1  LB SHIITAKE MUSHROOMS, FRESH

2 TABLESPOONS ITALIAN PARSLEY, CHOPPED

1 TEASPOON SCOTCH BONNET SALT (RECIPE FOLLOWS)

¼ CUP EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL

METHOD:

REMOVE STEMS FROM MUSHROOMS AND DISCARD. HEAT OLIVE OIL IN LARGE SKILLET OVER MEDIUM HEAT. PLACE MUSHROOMS BROWN SIDE DOWN IN SKILLET. LET MUSHROOMS SIT AND SAUTE IN THE OIL WITHOUT MOVING THEM FOR ABOUT 4 MINUTES. TURN OVER TO THE SIDE WITH THE GILLS AND COOK FOR AN ADDITIONAL 2 MINUTES.

REMOVE TO A LARGE BOWL AND TOSS IN SCOTCH BONNET BUTTER AND CHOPPED PARSLEY.

SERVE WARM AS A SIDE DISH OR ADD AS A FILLING TO OMELETTES,  TO PERK UP A WARM SALAD OR TO ADD A NEW DIMENSION TO POTATO SALAD.

SCOTCH BONNET SALT

Ingredients

20 Whole Fresh Scotch Bonnet Peppers roughly chopped

1/2 Cup coarse Kosher Salt (or sea salt)

1 Large Mortar & Pestle (or food processor)

Method:

Put both ingredients in mortar and pestle and pound until it is the texture of a chunky paste.

Work in batches if your mortar and pestle is not big enough to hold everything at once.

Nigel Spence, a Culinary Institute of America alumnus, was born in Kingston, Jamaica. Nigel freelanced at the Television Food Network for 3 years where he worked with culinary luminaries such as Bobby Flay and Emeril Lagasse. Chef Spence has appeared twice on Throwdown with Bobby Flay where he emerged the victor in cook offs against the Food Network star and was featured on CBS when he appeared on Tony’s Table as well as ABC’s Neighborhood Eats, NBC’s The Today Show , Sirius’ Everyday Living with Martha Stewart and TVFN’s Chopped. The acclaimed and New York Times-reviewed Ripe Kitchen and Bar is Mr Spence’s first entrepreneurial endeavour.

Popular Posts caribbean travel

The Caribbean Travel Awards 2025

More than 32 million people visited the Caribbean in 2023, and that number should be eclipsed by the end of this year. In other words, the Caribbean is more popular than ever — deepening its position not just as the world’s […]


The Cool List: The Caribbean’s Coolest Places to Stay in 2025, From Adventure Resorts to Historic Inns 

caribbean resorts 2025

It was one of the first major guides we at Caribbean Journal ever put together: The Cool List, whose first edition was back in 2013 and which remains an unrivaled curation of unique, character-filled, personality-driven, artful hotels around the Caribbean. […]


The 25 Best Best Beach Bars in the Caribbean for 2025, From Aruba to St Barth to Eleuthera  

antigua catherines cafe

You can find the perfect island. You can book the perfect hotel. But your vacation hasn’t really begun until you pull up to your chair with an ice-cold cocktail at the perfect Caribbean beach bar. For all of the wonders […]


Related Posts belize united airlines flights

United Is Adding a New Nonstop Flight to Belize

United Airlines is adding a new nonstop flight to Belize, Caribbean Journal has learned.  The new route will be connecting San Francisco with Belize, in another boost for the increasingly popular destination on the Caribbean coast of Central America.  The […]


The 25 Best Best Beach Bars in the Caribbean for 2025, From Aruba to St Barth to Eleuthera  

antigua catherines cafe

You can find the perfect island. You can book the perfect hotel. But your vacation hasn’t really begun until you pull up to your chair with an ice-cold cocktail at the perfect Caribbean beach bar. For all of the wonders […]


Delta Just Launched New More Nonstop Flights to Providenciales, Turks and Caicos 

palapas on grace bay beach in turks and caicos

There’s an increasingly important city for Caribbean travel: Detroit, Michigan. Delta has quietly been adding a number of new routes from the city to the Caribbean, including one flight that just kicked off late last month: nonstop service between Detroit […]