Harbour Island It’s about 3.5 miles long and about 1.5 miles wide, but there’s a whole lot happening on this little outpost off the coast of North Eleuthera. The vibe is beach chic, with just about everyone traveling around on golf carts and boutiques like the Island Company and India Hicks’ The Sugar Mill smack in the middle of downtown Dunmore Town. This is a kind of Caribbean Nantucket, safe and calm, ultra laid back and home to one of the Caribbean’s greatest beaches: Pink Sand Beach. Even better? There are some great conch spots all over the island, led by our favorite, Queen Conch, right on Bay Street in town. Where to stay? We like the Valentines resort and the old-school Dunmore boutique hotel.