Caneel Bay
St John’s best hotel is set on a 170-acre peninsula. The historic former Rockefeller estate, which is dotted with the ruins of an 18th-century sugar mill, is a throwback to the Caribbean as it once was, high on relaxation and low on bustle, with a pervasive elegance. And then there are the beaches — seven of them, meaning you’ll always be able to find your own beach hideaway.