Papa’s Pilar
This is a blend of rums from around the US and the Caribbean, but it’s distilled right in America (with operations soon to shift to Key West). Part of the proceeds go to the Hemingway Estate, as the rum is named for Papa’s famous fishing boat, Pilar. While the “blonde” variety is a terrific mixing rum and sippable in its own right, it’s the 24-year that’s the superstar.