Island Shop: Cayman Pepper Jelly

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - August 19, 2014

By Sarah Greaves-Gabbadon
CJ Travel Editor

It’s not every day that I recommend buying a $20 condiment. But it’s not every day that I come across a pepper jelly that tastes this good.

The pricey-but-worth-it spread is the creation of Caymanian Carol Hay, who uses fiery Scotch Bonnet peppers and 15 other secret ingredients in her “one-woman weekend operation” that yields three dozen mason jars of the relish a week.

Available in Grand Cayman supermarkets (I snagged mine in Bay Market at Camana Bay), the spread is definitely spicy but also deliciously sweet.

It’s the perfect accompaniment to cheese and crackers; can be combined with chicken stock to make a flavorful marinade; or mixed with sour cream, plain yogurt or mayo for a creamy dip with a Caribbean kick.

I’ve been told that because of all those peppers the preservative-free spread doesn’t need refrigeration, no matter how long you keep it in the cupboard.

But that’s never been an issue in my house. Because, as the label rightly says, it “never lasts long enough to expire.”

Popular Posts cape santa maria

From Anguilla to Aruba, the Best Caribbean Beaches to Visit This Summer

Forget the Hamptons, forget Santorini. And Florida? There’s a reason snowbirds go home in the summer. If you’re looking for a summertime beach getaway, the Caribbean is it. The water is deliciously warm, the trade winds keep you cool and […]

From Belize to Grenada, 10 Little Caribbean Beach Resorts to Visit Right Now 


There are different resorts for different vacations, different tastes, different moods. For some, there’s something delicious about a pint-sized, tiny Caribbean resort, where the emphasis is on the intimate, the serene. Where the soundtrack isn’t a piped-in DJ set, but […]

Curacao Travel Is Booming, With More Hotels, Added Flights and a New Energy 

curacao travel is booming beach

The colorful streets of Willemstad; the floating bridge; the all-day party at Mambo Beach; the endless possibilities at Jan Thiel. Curacao has always been one of the most diverse places to visit in the region. Now, travelers have finally started […]

Related Posts celebrity cruises bahamas

The Top-Rated Caribbean Cruise Lines, According to Travel Advisors

It’s hard picking a cruise option these days, as the industry continues to roar back in the last few years, along with a slew of new offerings. And there’s where a seasoned Caribbean travel expert can help. In an unofficial […]

New Nonstop Flights From Holland to Bonaire 


Corendon Dutch Airlines will begin twice weekly service from Amsterdam to Bonaire, following the success of its flights to Curaçao and what it called “growing demand” for holidays in Bonaire. The flight, which will operate on Wednesdays and Sundays, will make […]

Two New Hotels Are Coming to the Dominican Republic’s Capital 

st maarten dominican republic flights

A pair of new hotels will soon debut in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, part of the expansion of Southeast Asian operator Archipelago International.  The company, whose Caribbean operations have been focused in Cuba, will be opening two new hotels in […]


Sign up for Caribbean Journal's free newsletter for a daily dose of beaches, hotels, rum and the best Caribbean travel information on the net.

No. Thank You