Rum Journal: On Anguilla’s Scilly Cay, Rum Punch With a Side of Crayfish

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - August 18, 2014

Above: Scilly Cay, Anguilla

By Sarah Greaves-Gabbadon
CJ Travel Editor

You have to look hard to find bargains on the pricey Caribbean paradise of Anguilla, but they do exist. Our favorite? The rum punch served up at Scilly Cay, an islet just offshore from Island Harbour pier.

The specialty of the house is the creation of Eudoxie Wallace – better known as Gorgeous – proprietor of the sandy spit where the famously delicious crayfish and lobster platters will set you back $75. The potent potable, however, is a true bargain at just $5 a cup – which might explain why Gorgeous has been known to pour as many as 600 a day.

Concocted with about a half-glass of Mount Gay Eclipse; a generous pour of Amaretto; and a splash of fruit juice (“It’s expensive, so we don’t use that much,” Gorgeous says with a wink), it’s a “mind-eraser” that instantly puts you in an island state of mind. And also helps soothe the sting of your $75 meal.

Of course, you could pass on the punch and opt for something soft … bottled water, for example. But at $3 a time, it’s no bargain. And as Gorgeous says, “Why would you want to drink water? Fish f**k in that stuff!”

Rum punch that’s a better value than water? We’ll toast to that!

Popular Posts

A.R. Carnegie, 74, Caribbean Legal Legend

A Caribbean Journal Editorial He was never a judge, never a Queen’s Counsel. His robes were never silk. But A. Ralph Carnegie was a Caribbean John Marshall if there ever was one. Ralph Carnegie, A.R. in scholarly texts, passed away […]

Robinson: Manatt Approached Government

Lackston Robinson, Jamaica’s Deputy Solicitor General, testified that it was the law firm Manatt, Phelps and Phillips, and not the Jamaican Government/Jamaica Labour Party, that made the first move to solicit a contract to lobby the White House, he told […]

IMF Back in Antigua on Performance Review

The International Monetary Fund has sent a team to Antigua for a third review of the nation’s performance on a stand-by arrangement with the IMF. According to the Ministry of Finance, the IMF team began the review Monday and will […]

Related Posts pepe margo

A Rum Movement Is Growing in Aruba 

Down a quiet street in an industrial quarter of downtown Oranjestad sits a century-old home with brown wooden shutters and a barrel out front.  It’s an area that has become an increasingly hip corner of Aruba, home to a growing […]

More Cruise Ships Are Coming to Trinidad

trinidad cruise ship

Trinidad is projecting a significant jump in cruise passenger traffic this season.  The island’s tourism officials say “all signs point” to major gains in traffic, with the season set to begin in October and run through April of 2024.  The […]

Fortress' $425 Million Hotel Rebuild in St Thomas

the peninsula

The iconic Frenchman’s Reef resort complex in the U.S. Virgin Islands was built in 1973 and was a beloved Caribbean resort before it was shuttered in 2017 due to the massive devastation caused by hurricanes Irma and Maria. After years […]


Sign up for Caribbean Journal's free newsletter for a daily dose of beaches, hotels, rum and the best Caribbean travel information on the net.

No. Thank You