Op-Ed: Economic Sanctions and United States-Cuba Relations

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - February 20, 2012

By José Azel
Op-Ed Contributor

US economic sanctions against Cuba were first authorized in 1961 when President John F Kennedy issued an executive order in response to the Cuban government’s expropriation without compensation of American assets.

Five decades later, the issue remains unresolved and the topic still dominates the debates and the rhetoric surrounding US-Cuban relations

Some argue, with validity, that the sanctions have failed to change the course or nature of the Cuban government, but the failure argument is peculiarly offered in a form of isolated reverse logic that seeks a change in US policy.

It is also necessary to point out at the same time that the alternative policy pursued by the international community of engaging with the Cuban government has also failed to change the nature of that regime.

Currently, over 190 nations engage economically and politically with Cuba while the United States remains alone in enforcing its economic sanctions policy. If, indeed, US policy is deemed as one case of failure to change the nature of the Cuban government, there are 190 cases of failure on the same grounds. By a preponderance of evidence (190 to 1) the case can be made that engagement with that regime has been a dismal failure.

Fifty years ago, President John F. Kennedy sent a reasonable message to the international community that governments that choose to expropriate the properties of US citizens need to compensate them. Governments that choose to simply steal the properties of US citizens should expect some form of retaliation from the US government. That message remains valid today as an expression of a government’s duty to protect the property rights of its citizenry in foreign countries where the rule of law does not prevail.

It is one thing to argue, as those of us that value personal freedoms do, that investors should be free to invest and accept all the risks of their decisions when the rules of the game are known in advance and where the rule of law prevails.

Investors in communist countries cannot expect their government’s protection; they know in advance what they are getting into. The maxim “investors beware” is fully in place. After all, Karl Marx makes it clear in chapter two of The Communist Manifesto that “…the theory of the Communists may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property.”

It is a different situation when the rules are capriciously and arbitrarily changed after the fact, as the Cuban government did, and where no legal recourse is available.

Independently of their usefulness, the use of economic sanctions as a foreign policy tool is neither new nor particularly American. Pericles’ decree banning the Megarians from the Athenian market and ports helped incite the Peloponnesian War in 431 BC.

Unintended and undesirable consequences are inherent in the use of economic sanctions. Arguably they should not be used to compel a democratic transformation or even to advance human rights or other laudable goals.

They seem, however, an appropriate in-kind response to the economic aggression of another country such as expropriations without compensation. What are the policy alternatives to protect the property rights of a citizenry when negotiations fail or when a government refuses to offer compensation to foreign investors?

Dr Jose Azel

Dr José Azel is a Senior Scholar at the University of Miami’s Institute for Cuban and Cuban-American Studies, and the author of the book, Mañana in Cuba.

Note: the opinions expressed in Caribbean Journal op-eds are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Caribbean Journal.

Popular Posts antigua catherines cafe

The 25 Best Best Beach Bars in the Caribbean for 2025, From Aruba to St Barth to Eleuthera  

You can find the perfect island. You can book the perfect hotel. But your vacation hasn’t really begun until you pull up to your chair with an ice-cold cocktail at the perfect Caribbean beach bar. For all of the wonders […]


The 25 Best All-Inclusive Resorts in the Caribbean for 2025, From Beach Hotels to Private Hideaways to Overwater Bungalows

all-inclusive resorts caribbean

Today’s travelers want experiences. They want great food. They want authenticity. They want thoughtful service. But if you’re been following the travel industry in the last half-decade, you know that what today’s travelers really want are all-inclusive resorts. The all-inclusive […]


Hyatt Is Closing This Riviera Maya Resort, With Plans for a Rebranding

riviera maya resort closing

Hyatt is closing one of its top luxury resorts in the Mexican Caribbean in a few months, with plans for a rebranding, Caribbean Journal has learned.  The Andaz Mayakoba Resort Riviera Maya, one of a trio of properties in the […]


Related Posts the new stadium

There's a New Baseball Stadium in The Bahamas 

Miami Marlins star Jazz Chisholm just might be the most famous baseball player ever from The Bahamas.  But the reality is that Chisholm is part of a growing wave of high-level baseball talent coming from The Bahamas, a growing baseball […]


Blue Diamond Resorts Takes Over Iconic Havana Hotel 

havana hotel blue diamond

Blue Diamond Resorts has taken over management of one of the most iconic hotels in Havana, Cuba, Caribbean Journal has learned.  The company, which is in the midst of another major expansion push in Cuba, is now operating and managing […]


Sunwing Is Adding More Flights to Cuba, Cancun

Cancun Punta Cana Vacations

Sunwing is making its return to the city of Thunder Bay in Ontario this winter.  The Canadian travel giant will be relaunching flights from Thunder Bay to both Cancun, Mexico and Varadero, Cuba this winter.  That will include weekly flights […]