Law

CCJ Makes First Belize Judgment

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - June 28, 2011

Above: the Caribbean Court of Justice

By Alexander Britell

Belize saw its first-ever judgment from the Caribbean Court of Justice, with the court finding that the Attorney General was allowed to bring an action for misfeasance in office against two former ministers, Florencio Marin and Jose Coye, alleged to have wrongfully sold government land.

The Attorney General of Belize had filed the claim against the ministers alleging that, during their time in office, they had arranged the transfer of 56 parcels of state-owned land to a company that was beneficially owned and/or controlled by one of them.

The claim of misfeasance in tort involving public officials had typically been extended only to private citizens or classes of persons, but the court upheld the Court of Appeal’s ruling that it could be extended to an action by the Attorney General, although it used slightly different reasoning.

CCJ Justice Desiree Bernard noted that while “all of the cases on the tort of misfeasance brought in the jurisdiction where it has been utilized have been at the instance of individuals,” not state officials,”at the end of the day” it was the duty of the Attorney General to preserve the patrimony of Belize by “recovering financial loss from those allegedly responsible for undervaluing national lands in their quest for personal financial gain.”

The five-judge panel originally heard the case in November included former CCJ President Michael de la Bastide. Bastide was replaced by Sir Charles Michael Dennis Byron in March.

The dissent argued that such cases were within the purview of the criminal law, and that the tort should not encompass civil actions by the state.

The original action, Attorney General of Belize v Florencio Marin and Jose Coye, alleged that the consideration paid by the purchasing company was $1 million below market value, and that it had been transacted without lawful authority and in bad faith. The action involved a single cause of action — misfeasance in public office.

Attorney Magali Marin Young declined to comment on the case. Co-defense counsel Elson Kaseke could not be reached for comment.

The Belize Court of Appeal had reversed a decision by the Supreme Court of Belize, finding that former ministers could be held liable in misfeasance for loss of public property, and that the Attorney General was the proper party to institute proceedings.

Attorneys Nigel Ovid Hawke and Lois Michelle Young SC, who represented the Attorney General, were similarly unavailable for comment.

The case cited to fairly broad precedent — from a decision by the House of Lords in Brayser v. McLean, to the Privy Council’s ruling in Three Rivers District Council v. Bank of England to the Inter-American Convention against Corruption, to a number of Indian cases on which the Court of Appeal had focused (although the court disagreed with the Court of Appeal’s understanding of the Indian precedent).

The CCJ found that, while the Attorney General’s action was “unprecedented,” there was no “sufficient reason” to deny the logic of the developments of the tort of misfeasance and what the court termed “evolution of the corporate nature of the State in the law of torts.”

The question of the CCJ has returned to Caribbean news of late, with several governments divided over whether to retain the London-based Privy Council or to sign on to the CCJ, as three countries — Belize, Guyana and Barbados, have already done. Belize joined the court last year.

The case is now headed back to the Supreme Court.

Popular Posts adults only hotels resorts caribbean

Americans Are Flocking to the Island of St Lucia Right Now

Maybe it’s the scenery. Or perhaps it’s the hiking. Or the rainforests. Or the island’s stunning resorts.  But one thing is clear: Americans are falling in love with St Lucia again, with US travel to the Eastern Caribbean island continuing […]


Caribbean Airlines Is Bringing Back This Nonstop Flight to Kingston, Jamaica 

jamaica caribbean airlines kingston

The art scene. The music history. The flavors. The new-look downtown. Kingston, Jamaica is hotter than ever, as travelers have begun discovering its myriad charms — and an impressive new slate of hotels all over the capital.  It’s also easier […]


Riu Just Relaunched This Punta Cana All-Inclusive Resort With Nearly 1,000 Rooms 

Riu All-Inclusive Punta Cana

It wasn’t your typical renovation in the Caribbean. All-inclusive brand Riu actually demolished one of its Bavaro Beach-area resorts to pave way for a massive expansion of the one next door.  The result? The new-look, significantly larger all-inclusive Riu Palace […]


Related Posts alaia belize

Marriott’s Belize Resort Just Unveiled Its New-Look Spa

There’s a new-look spa at Marriott’s signature Autograph Collection resort in Belize: Alaia, which has unveiled an expanded wellness destination at its Ambergris Caye retreat.  The K’In Spa and Wellness Center has completed what Alaia is calling a “significant renovation […]


Caribbean Moment: Finding Serenity in Belize’s Mountain Pine Ridge Forest 

belize mountain ridge

If you know Belize, you know it’s a whole universe of destinations. Sure, you have the beachy hotspots like Ambergris Caye and Caye Caulker.  But venture inland to the Cayo District and you’ll find untold natural wonders: pristine forests, rivers, […]


The Best Food Tour in Belize Is a Journey Through Ambergris Caye 

belize food tour best

Tio Pil was born here when it was just a fishing village, went to work on the Panama Canal, and came back on his cargo boat. Pil, whose real name was Felipe Paz, helped to bring some of the first […]